This photo shows the narrowing of the YF-102A fuselage near the wings as dictated by the Area Rule compared to the fuselage of the YF-102. It enabled the aircraft to become supersonic.
To overcome high drag loads at transonic speeds, Convair engineers redesigned the fuselage and wing. The fuselage design used the "area-rule" which resulted in the characteristic "coke bottle" shape.
The Delta Dagger YF-102 on Rogers Dry Lake. This is the first YF-102 built.
The XB-70 Valkyrie, built as a bomber, used a Delta wing configuration. Due to budget limitations, only two were built and they were used as research planes.
The Concorde needed a delta wing to achieve its high, sustained cruising speed of Mach 2.
The delta wings can easily be seen on this photograph of the Shuttle orbiter Columbia.
Sometimes, a technology persists despite its problems and eventually is rescued by other technologies. The delta wing story provides an excellent example.
A delta wing is a wing whose shape when viewed from above looks like a triangle, often with its tip cut off. It sweeps sharply back from the fuselage with the angle between the leading edge (the front) of the wing often as high as 60 degrees and the angle between the fuselage and the trailing edge of the wing at around 90 degrees. Often delta-wing airplanes lack horizontal stabilizers. Despite the fact that paper airplanes have delta wings and appear to fly quite well when launched from a height, delta wings actually perform poorly at low speeds and often are unstable (i.e., they do not stay in level flight on their own). Their primary advantage is efficiency in high-speed flight.
The first patent for a delta-wing aircraft design was granted to Englishmen J.W. Butler and E. Edwards in 1867. Their aircraft design would have used a jet-propulsion system, with thrust provided by rockets, compressed air jets, steam, or gunpowder, had it ever flown. Like many advanced concepts, not until the combatants in World War II conducted actual wind tunnel tests did large numbers of aircraft designers start to take the delta wing seriously. Professor Alexander M. Lippisch of Germany, best known for developing the Messerschmitt Me 163 Komet rocket fighter, began thinking about supersonic airplanes during the 1940s. He chose the delta shape and constructed a wooden glider to be launched from high altitude by a transport plane. The Allies captured the unflown glider at the end of the war and sent it to the United States for study. Lippisch also came to the United States where he worked on supersonic flight for the U.S. Army Air Forces, the predecessor to the U.S. Air Force.
Soon after the end of the war, Convair, a U.S. manufacturer of bombers, began work on a supersonic interceptor aircraft with a delta wing. The company's engineers began testing models in wind tunnels before building a full-size aircraft. The XF-92A first flew from Muroc Air Base (later Edwards Air Force Base) in 1948. Its designers gave it an extremely large vertical tail, thought necessary because of fears that the large delta wing might block airflow to the tail and make the plane impossible to control. Flight tests with the XF-92 proved that a large tail was unnecessary.
By 1953, Convair's engineers had developed the YF-102 Delta Dagger, a radical design that lacked a horizontal tail and featured a large, sharply swept delta wing. Wind tunnel tests of small-scale models indicated that the aircraft could accelerate through Mach 1 (the speed of sound) with relative ease, rather than "punching" through it like earlier experimental planes that had to burn a lot of fuel to go faster than Mach 1. However, the first prototype unexpectedly encountered immense drag as it approached Mach 1. This so-called "transonic" region presented a major problem for the aircraft.
Near the same time, Richard T. Whitcomb, an aeronautical scientist at the National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics (NACA), was studying transonic drag. Whitcomb developed what he called the "supersonic area rule." This theory stated that aircraft that would fly at supersonic speed should increase in cross-sectional area from a pointed nose. Anything that protruded into the airstream, such as the canopy over the cockpit, wings, or tail, should be accompanied by a reduction in cross-section elsewhere. In 1954, Whitcomb, who was then only 33-years old, was awarded the prestigious Collier Trophy for this contribution to aeronautics.
Convair's designers quickly applied the supersonic area rule to a new aircraft, the YF-102A, pinching the fuselage near its mid-point to give it a slightly hourglass (or Coke-bottle) appearance. This was a compromise for an existing aircraft; later airplanes included the area rule in their designs in much less obvious ways. When the first YF-102A with this new design took flight, it easily accelerated through Mach 1.
During the 1950s the delta wing was used on several aircraft that had a need for speed, including the B-58 Hustler and the canceled XB-70 Valkyrie bomber. The Soviet Union used a delta wing for its failed Tu-144 supersonic passenger jet, and for its famed MiG-21, one of the most widely-used fighter jets of the Cold War. The French also adopted the delta for its successful Dassault Mirage III.
The two most famous current aircraft to use the delta wing are the Concorde and the Space Shuttle. The Concorde's delta wing made the plane's sustained cruising speed of Mach 2 possible. The Space Shuttle's wing, known as a "cranked delta" because the leading edge of the wing has a slight bend near its midpoint, is used for a different purpose. The Space Shuttle originally had what was known as a "high crossrange" requirement, which was the ability to glide for thousands of miles to either side of its flight path when landing. Conventional straight wings did not provide enough lift at high speeds and altitudes to achieve this type of range, and so the large delta wing was necessary.
While delta wings are critical to achieving high lift for supersonic flight, they also have a number of disadvantages for less high-performing aircraft. They require high landing and takeoff speeds and long takeoff and landing runs, are unstable at high angles of attack, and produce tremendous drag when "trimmed" to keep the plane level. Of these disadvantages, pilots and designers usually consider the high landing and takeoff speeds the most important because they make flying the plane dangerous. Indeed, when the Concorde had its first ever crash in 2000, after two decades of safe operations, the high-speed takeoff was a factor in this terrible accident, for the plane's high ground speed before becoming airborne placed major stress upon the aircraft's tires, which exploded upon striking an object on the runway.
By the 1980s, except for the Concorde and Space Shuttle, the delta wing appeared headed for obsolescence. Its drawbacks made it unattractive and changes in fighter warfare reduced the requirement for sustained supersonic speed. Few aircraft spend much time traveling at high supersonic speeds because it burns so much fuel, rendering the delta wing, which is primarily useful for supersonic flight, less attractive. But the computer and an additional flight control device called the canard have rescued the delta wing from obsolescence.
Computer-controlled "fly-by-wire" flight control systems have allowed designers to compensate for some of the delta wing's poor control qualities. Canards are small horizontal fins (or small wings) mounted on the fuselage in front of an aircraft's main wings to provide greater control, particularly during high angles of attack. When they are part of a delta-wing aircraft, they improve its stability and maneuverability.
Several aircraft appeared in the 1980s and 1990s that incorporated both delta wings and canards. The latest delta-wing aircraft are the Swedish JAS 39 Grippen, the Dassault Rafale naval fighter (designed to be launched from the French aircraft carrier Charles de Gaulle), the Indian Light Combat Aircraft, or LCA, and the Eurofighter Typhoon. The Typhoon, which had its first flight in the mid-1990s, is a joint European effort (Britain, Germany, Italy and Spain, with France withdrawing early) to develop an advanced fighter to replace a number of different aging aircraft in their air forces. Thus, the delta wing, which seemed destined for obsolescence, has gained a new lease on life.
--Dwayne A. Day
Sources and further reading:
The World's Great Interceptor Aircraft, London: W.H. Smith Ltd., 1989.
The World's Great Attack Aircraft, London: W.H. Smith Ltd., 1988.
Hewson, Robert. "Saab JAS 39 Grippen." World Airpower Journal, Autumn/Fall 2000, 60-103.
Mendenhall, Charles A. Delta Wings. Osceola, WI: Motorbooks International, 1983.
Spick, Mike. "Europe's New Fighters," in Spick, Mike, ed. The Great Book of Modern Warplanes. London: Salamander Books, 2000.